AniLumi home

Head to head

Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei vs Shugo Chara!

Side by side on community score, how it's rated, audience size and how long each takes to watch. Data from Kitsu, refreshed daily.

The short version

  • Scores are effectively tied: 7.32 vs 7.39.
  • Shugo Chara! is more widely watched, with 23× the members.
  • They take about the same time to watch (20h 24m vs 20h 24m).
  • Fans favorite Shugo Chara! more often (1.2% vs 0.3% of members).
  • They share School Life, Comedy.
Mama wa Shougaku 4 NenseiShugo Chara!
Community score7.327.39higher
Rank by score#3,486#3,084better
Members69015,865more
Favorited by0.3%1.2%more
Time to watch20h 24m20h 24m
Episodes5151
FormatTV SeriesTV Series
Aired19922007–2008
StatusFinishedFinished
StudioSunriseSatelight
Age ratingPGPG

How each is rated

Share of ratings at each star level · 9★–10★: 23% vs 26%

  • Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei
  • Shugo Chara!
0%15%30%
1★2★3★4★5★6★7★8★9★10★
Show as table
Mama wa Shougaku 4 NenseiShugo Chara!
1★0%1%
2★2%1%
3★1%1%
4★4%4%
5★8%7%
6★16%14%
7★25%24%
8★20%23%
9★8%9%
10★15%16%

Time to watch

Episodes × episode length, openings included

Show as table
ItemRuntime
Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei20h 24m
Shugo Chara!20h 24m

Only Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei

Shared genres

Only Shugo Chara!

More comparisons

Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei vs Shugo Chara! FAQ

Is Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei better than Shugo Chara!?

By community score, Shugo Chara! is ahead (7.39 vs 7.32). Both are school life and comedy, so taste decides the rest.

Which is longer, Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei or Shugo Chara!?

Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei is longer: 20h 24m against 20h 24m.

Which is more popular?

Shugo Chara! has more members on Kitsu (15,865 vs 690).

If I liked Mama wa Shougaku 4 Nensei, will I like Shugo Chara!?

Probably, if it was the school life, comedy side you enjoyed.